Why Domestic Violence Against Women is Permitted in Islam?

July 72011

I came across this verse in Quran no 4:3 that promotes wive beating "If you fear high-handedness from your wives, remind them [of the teaching of God], then ignore them when you go to bed, then hit them. If they obey you, you have no right to act against them. God is most high and great."

Interesting really, in Australia I would be charged if I suggested that you treat your dog this way

Can violence against women be considered a form of domestic terrorism?

June 212011

Jane Velez Mitchell who hosts the show Issues on HLN said that on one episode. She believes that there is a war on women.

Random crimes that have no connection to each other can not be called "terror tactics", nor are random acts that have no connection to each other constitute a "war". You don’t assume that mother nature is at "war" with us just because random wind storms destroy people’s homes, for example.

A "terrorist act"is a preplanned attack designed to achieve some larger political goal, and it is usually part of a larger plan. I don’t believe that people who get into a physical altercation in a heat of passion are committing a predetermined political act as part of some coordinated grand scheme by some invisible patriarchal organization to subjugate women. I’m not some conspiracy theory nut. Believe it or not, men do not hold weekly meetings about how best to oppress women, nor do we go to training camps to learn the latest "wife beating" techniques.

What are some counter arguments for domestic violence against women?

June 82011

Writing an argumentative paper for English.

You’re thoughts and help are much appreciated :)

Counter arguments for domestic violence against women? None under the law. The law is pretty clear. Now to argue self-defense is another story, something that the male will have to prove in the case of domestic violence against the female. However, self-defense can sometimes be difficult to prove in court in the case of domestic violence.
Culturally some people consider women as property or second class citizens. Thus violence against them when they mess up is morally and rationally justified in their eyes.

My father – domestic violence and violence against women – help please!?

June 52011

My mother and I (a girl) experience domestic violence from my father. When he’s normal, he’s nice. When we fight, he pulls our hair and throws us around by our hair. It’s been going on since I was born 16 years ago. Recently, after a verbal attack on him by my mother, he got up and chased her – I intervened and he ran to the kitchen, CHOSE THE BIGGEST KNIFE AND CHASED ME INTO THE BEDROOM WITH A MURDEROUS FACE. I locked the door before he could get in but I thought I was going to die by his hand.

Mum hasn’t divorced him because essentially he’s unable to function in an English-speaking society – Australia, (mum learnt English here fine, she thought he could too) despite my parents being here for 18 years from China. Our family has no support network and we can’t make a public spectacle of ourselves. My parents’ only friends are relatives here who know but don’t offer any real assistance. I have no idea how we can continue living like this, please help.

The worst part is that he has never apologised or promised that things will change. He has NOT felt any regret and has NOT said sorry EVER – because he believes that what he does to us isn’t called hitting – because he hasn’t technically thrown a punch. My mother and I say it is – it’s physically harming. This is why I can’t tell anyone – because no one BELIEVES US.

What’s going to happen when the police come? He has no money whatsoever, not even enough to buy a week’s worth of food, much less rent a hotel room or anything. We will have to take care of him till he dies no matter what – his brothers don’t give a **** about him because they know once they let him into their lives, he will never leave.

Also, respect for your elders is paramount in Chinese culture – for some reason I am expected to just accept this. It’s different. Your elders are always right even when they are wrong. People joke about hitting your jokes in Chinese sitcoms! There was this scene where a kid failed a test and his mother was chasing him around with a frying pan and there was canned laughter in the background!
‘m a scared teenage girl living under the rule of a cruel and unreasonable father – I have never told anyone close to me who doesn’t already know about this because they wouldn’t understand, if you think it’s so easy to escape from such terror in your own household, you obviously have never been through anything like this – a situation like this. Please don’t insult my culture – 4000 years of rules and how to be is not easily changed and broken with a simple ‘that’s enough’. The one time I do tell people, they throw it in my face saying I am a coward – if I am, don’t I have every right to be? But I am not a coward – I tell him when he is wrong, I stand up to him when he hits my mother and I refuse to back down. We threaten him with everything legal, but what does it matter to him? He’s lost everything he has ever had – a career, a reputation, friends, the love of his family, his body and has absolutely nothing left to gain.
left to lose*
It’s not like I’m a fully legal adult with the choice to leave home – I’m stuck here for another 2 years. These past 2 years are when I have actually stood up to him, I have already reiterated how he is totally unreasonable, plus he is a grown man of 5′11 and I am a teenage girl of 5′5 – how could I possibly hope to beat him in a physical fight?

Im in Australia and I believe you! Why do you think no one else will? Domestic violence is illegal here, ALL domestic violence. Your father, if your migration to Australia was legal and he has permanant residency, has access to all of the usual government assistance.

You and your Mum need to leave, and you need to take an AVO (apprehended violence order) out on your father so that he stays away. What your dad is doing to you and your mum is wrong and you need to put a stop to it. It matters not at all what culture your parents are from, you live in Australia and that means living by our laws. Those laws say that what your father does to you both is wrong. If you want to talk, email me via my profile page.

ETA for OP: You CAN leave sweetie, not saying that it would be easy, I know that its not….but you have the right and the need for a safe environment and here in Australia that IS your legal right.

Why do some people try to pass of cases of domestic violence against women as isolated issues?

May 272011

"The problem is so widespread that it can’t be explained away with the "few bad apples" theory; we cannot write off all perpetrators of sexual harassment, battering, rape, sexual assault and deadly violence against girls and women as psychotic or evil. Violence against women is far too common an occurrence not to look at it as a societal issue that needs a serious and broad-based response."

http://www.now.org/issues/violence/101006school_shootings.html

NOW, now thats a credible source.

People that make money off of women feeling victimized.

Domestic violence and violence against women – help please!?

May 162011

My mother and I (a girl) experience domestic violence from my father. When he’s normal, he’s nice. When we fight, he throws us around a room by our hair. It’s been going on since I was born 16 years ago. Recently, after a verbal attack on him by my mother, he got up and chased her – I intervened and he ran to the kitchen, CHOSE THE BIGGEST KNIFE AND CHASED ME INTO THE BEDROOM WITH A MURDEROUS FACE. I locked the door before he could get in but I thought I was going to die by his hand.

Mum hasn’t divorced him because essentially he’s unable to function in an English-speaking society – Australia, (mum learnt English here fine, she thought he could too) despite my parents being here for 18 years from China. Our family has no support network and we can’t make a public spectacle of ourselves. My parents’ only friends are relatives here who know but don’t offer any real assistance. I have no idea how we can continue living like this, please help.

The worst part is that he has never apologised or promised that things will change.
He has NOT felt any regret and has NOT said sorry EVER – because he believes that what he does to us isn’t called hitting – because he hasn’t technically thrown a punch. My mother and I say it is – it’s physically harming. This is why I can’t tell anyone – because no one BELIEVES US.
What’s going to happen when the police come? He has no money whatsoever, not even enough to buy a week’s worth of food, much less rent a hotel room or anything. We will have to take care of him till he dies no matter what – his brothers don’t give a shit about him because they know once they let him into their lives, he will never leave.
Also, respect for your elders is paramount in Chinese culture – for some reason I am expected to just accept this. It’s different. Your elders are always right even when they are wrong. People joke about hitting your jokes in Chinese sitcoms! There was this scene where a kid failed a test and his mother was chasing him around with a frying pan and there was canned laughter in the background!
I’m a scared teenage girl living under the rule of a cruel and unreasonable father – I have never told anyone close to me who doesn’t already know about this because they wouldn’t understand, if you think it’s so easy to escape from such terror in your own household, you obviously have never been through anything like this – a situation like this. Please don’t insult my culture – 4000 years of rules and how to be is not easily changed and broken with a simple ‘that’s enough’. The one time I do tell people, they throw it in my face saying I am a coward – if I am, don’t I have every right to be? But I am not a coward – I tell him when he is wrong, I stand up to him when he hits my mother and I refuse to back down. We threaten him with everything legal, but what does it matter to him? He’s lost everything he has ever had – a career, a reputation, friends, the love of his family, his body and has absolutely nothing left to gain.

It’s not like I’m a fully legal adult with the choice to le
*It’s not like I’m a fully legal adult with the choice to leave home – I’m stuck here for another 2 years. These past 2 years are when I have actually stood up to him, I have already reiterated how he is totally unreasonable, plus he is a grown man of 5′11 and I am a teenage girl of 5′5 – how could I possibly hope to beat him in a physical fight?

Saving Face is the essence of your culture, but you are not in China. You need to ask yourself if this man was a stranger coming at you and your mother with a knife what would you do? You and your mum need help, go to the police they should be abel to assist you with shelter. You and mum come first; if dad has not learn english in 18 years than he will learn fast when is support system is gone. You only get one life and dad does not get to decide how long you get to have it.

I see you thing that making a public spectacle is a problem, but if dad get the knife the next time and hurt you or mum or even worst the public spectacle will be in a court of law where your dad will have to face your entire community.

All cultures have rules of respect for elders, you are not disrespecting your elder you are trying to save your life. You are still a child having to make an adult decision and that is to choose to live or die for the sake of culture. Make this easy on yourself let the authorities help you and your mother, you are not responsible for your father; if the authorities take your father away he will be forced to figure out how to eat (there are places) put a roof over his head (there are places) and in time when you are safe and educated you can help him if you are alive. You need help call the authorities.

Call the authorities let them help.

Shalom

opinion about domestic violence against women?

May 132011

i need your opinion

If a man abuses his woman once
and later on she lets him do it again
Its her fault because she didn’t leave him when he first abused her

I heard that Shari’a Law endorses domestic violence against women…?

May 112011

Is this true? Citations?

under Shari’a law, if a woman even steps outside of her home, without being fully covered, and without a male escort, she is to be killed.
If she is not a virgin when she gets married, her new husband must kill her for being unfaithful to him.
If a man decides that he want to have sex with her, she can not refuse to marry him. this is why there are female suicide bombers. After they had been married, and are not a virgin, if another man wants to marry her, and finds that she is not a virgin, he will kill her, so for her it is better that her death leads to the deaths of infidels, so that all her sins will be forgiven, and she can enter paradise.
If she marries a non-muslim, her family must kill her to restore honor to the family.

what are the causes of domestic violence against women?

April 232011


liquor, drugs, poverty, religion, societal attitudes, chicken shit people who beat women

How can violence against women be reduced? Other than domestic violence?

April 162011

I am writing a paper on how to reduce the violence attacks against women in my hometown. i have already though of ways to possibly reduce domestic violence but how could the numbers of robberies and assault be reduced as well

Stop the pampering that goes on in the court system. They used to actually punish people that did something against the law. Now it is just a little slap on the wrist and they go home. This teaches nothing. Make it painful for someone that does this by some jail time for a few months the first time. Not time number 12.